The American Variant of Tall Poppy Syndrome: A Cultural Analysis
Gracious words are like a honeycomb, sweetness to the soul and health to the body. Proverbs 16:4
In the landscape of social phenomena, Tall Poppy Syndrome (TPS) - the tendency to criticize or sabotage successful individuals - presents an intriguing cultural paradox, particularly in its American manifestation. While traditionally associated with Australian culture, the American variant of TPS reveals distinct characteristics that reflect deeper aspects of American values, social dynamics, and cultural expectations (detailed in The Tall Poppy Syndrome - The Joy of Cutting Others Down).
The American Modification: Beyond Simple Envy
The American version of TPS diverges significantly from its Australian counterpart and is divided into two components. Australians are egalitarian and envious of those with more (tall poppies). American envy and other dark emotions are directed at people within their tribes - families, schools, neighborhoods, and work - and are not necessarily tall poppies (Private TPS).
Another form of American TPS (Public TPS) is intrinsically linked to the concept of "deservingness" - a cultural litmus test that evaluates success and the perceived legitimacy of how that success was achieved. This modification reflects a uniquely American perspective on achievement, where the path to success matters as much as the success itself. It is our paradox of rewarding victimhood as much as merit.
The Role of Merit and Ethics
Meritocracy is central to understanding American TPS, deeply embedded in the American Dream. Americans are less likely to resent those who succeed through demonstrable hard work and ethical behavior. However, the cultural response can be swift and severe when success is perceived as unearned or achieved through questionable means. This explains why figures like Martha Stewart, who achieved remarkable success but faced public backlash after perceived ethical transgressions, became targets of American TPS.
Political and Ideological Dimensions
The phenomenon takes on additional complexity when viewed through political and ideological lenses. Liberals, who typically prioritize fairness and harm avoidance, may exhibit TPS tendencies when confronting disparities in wealth and power. Conservatives often approach TPS differently - targeting those who challenge traditional hierarchies or established social orders. This ideological split demonstrates how American TPS operates across the political spectrum, though motivated by different values and concerns.
Institutional Manifestations
Perhaps most distinctively, American TPS can manifest at an institutional level, with the government potentially acting as a "cutter." This aspect reveals a unique tension between individual success and institutional power in American society. Examples range from the IRS targeting of specific political groups to the military's treatment of whistleblowers like Billy Mitchell, highlighting how institutional forces can work to regulate and sometimes suppress individual achievement.
Historical Case Studies
The phenomenon is best understood through specific examples across American history. Consider the cases of robber barons like Franklin B. Gowan, whose downfall came after years of ruthless business practices, or more recent examples like the Enron scandal and Elizabeth Holmes of Theranos. These cases demonstrate how American society tends to tolerate and celebrate success until evidence of unethical behavior emerges, at which point the cutting down can be particularly severe.
The Military Context
Military examples provide particularly poignant illustrations of American TPS. The cases of Eddie Slovic and Captain Charles McVay III demonstrate how institutional powers can make examples of individuals, often unfairly, to maintain order or deflect responsibility. These cases reveal how American TPS can sometimes serve as a tool for institutional control and scapegoating. Let us not forget that the ancient descriptions of Greece and Rome TPS involved civil leaders cutting down opposition.
The Path Forward: Positive Tall Poppies
Despite these challenging aspects, the American experience with TPS offers a constructive path forward. The concept of the "positive tall poppy" emerges as an alternative model - individuals who achieve success while maintaining ethical standards and contributing positively to society. Fred Smith, the founder of FedEx, exemplifies this approach, having built his success on principle-centered leadership and ethical business practices.
Peter Singer, an Australian and author of The Life You Can Save, is credited with starting a movement titled "effective altruism" (EA). EA's concept is to use evidence and reason to figure out how to benefit others as much as possible and to use money efficiently. Many TPs have virtue-signaled their embrace of EA almost in anticipation of eventually being cut down. Sam Bankman-Fried is an example although to no avail personally and legally.
Some service or servitude is one of the best attributes a TP can embrace. It can be practiced by the rich and poor. It is a roadmap to Tall Poppydom and diminishes TPS.
The Role of Relationships and Community
Successful navigation of American TPS often involves understanding the importance of relationships and community support. True achievement isn't accomplished in isolation but through collaboration and mutual support. This understanding helps create a more sustainable model of success that's less likely to trigger TPS responses.
Legacy and Impact
The ultimate measure of success in avoiding or transcending American TPS may lie in the question of legacy. When individuals focus not just on personal achievement but on their broader impact and contribution to society through servitude, they're more likely to be viewed as legitimate success stories rather than targets for cutting down.
Conclusion
The American variant of Tall Poppy Syndrome reflects complex cultural values and social dynamics unique to the United States. Understanding this phenomenon requires recognizing how it differs from its Australian counterpart and appreciating its connections to deeply held American values about merit, ethics, and success. While tall poppydom can manifest itself in destructive ways, the positive tall poppy offers a constructive alternative - achievement that combines excellence with ethical behavior and positive social impact.
This modified understanding of TPS suggests that in America, the goal isn't to avoid standing tall but to grow in a way that strengthens rather than diminishes the field around you. Success, when achieved through ethical means and coupled with positive social impact, can resist the cutting forces of American TPS while contributing to a more constructive model of achievement in American society.
Tall Poppy Syndrome Newsletter
Join the newsletter to receive the latest updates in your inbox.
